Asia Pacific Women in Leadership Mentoring Program

Asia Pacific Women in Leadership Mentoring Program

DEBUNK: The Model Minority Myth

WHAT IS THE MODEL MINORITY MYTH?

The “model minority” myth commonly refers to East, Southeast and South Asian communities in North America that are considered to be inherently advantageous, intelligent, and hardworking compared to other minority groups. 

The term “model minority” was coined in the United States by sociologist William Petersen in 1966 during the civil rights movement.

The concept of a model minority creates a false positive and a harmful narrative that reinforces systemic racism, does more damage than good, and ignores significant anti-Asian racism that many have experienced throughout Canadian history. 

IT ERASES THE DIVERSITY AMONG DIFFERENT INDIVIDUALS

The model minority myth groups the experiences and sentiments of a large group of people under one misrepresented stereotype, the myth actively eliminates any kind of diversity among Asian communities and places immense pressure on individuals to fit the unreal stereotype. For example, did you know the poverty rate of Chinese Canadians is double that of white Canadians at 22 percent. 

This myth actively eliminates any kind of diversity among Asian communities and places immense pressure on individuals to fit the unreal and problematic stereotype. 

IT PERCEIVES ASIAN CANADIANS AS PERPETUAL FOREIGNERS

The myth groups all Asians under a single stereotype, and thus separates them from the rest of the population. Perceived as only possessing foreign qualities, the myth renders Asians as perpetual foreigners and raises questions like “But where are you from, originally?”

Did you know Canada benefits greatly from the ongoing contributions of Asian Canadians. Contributions dating back to 1884 when 15,000 Chinese labourers completed the BC section of the CPR, with more than 600 of them perishing under adverse working conditions. 

IT ERASES THE RACISM FACED BY ASIANS IN THE PAST & PRESENT

Stereotyping Asians as “privileged” and “successful” ignores the historical and ongoing struggles and the systemic, and institutionalized discrimination and racism that has impacted and continues to impact these communities. 

The myth disregards Canada’s problematic anti-Asian history, including the Chinese head tax, the Chinese Exclusion Act, Japanese internment during World War Two, and the Komagata Maru incident. 

The model minority myth completely ignores centuries of systematic, institutional, and structural discrimination and racism, which many continue to experience the impacts of to this day. 

IT HINDERS THE FIGHT FOR RACIAL JUSTICE

The success of most Asian communities is often held as an example for other minorities to strive for and suggests that if other groups simply “work harder” and “get over their histories of oppression”, they too can succeed.  

This is simply incorrect. 

It pits people of colour against each other. The myth is a tool of colonialism and increases the obstacles of achieving racial justice and liberation for all. 

 

Sources & Contributions

The Model Minority Myth (thepractice.law.harvard.edu)

What Is the Model Minority Myth? (learningforjustice.org)

The Model Minority Myth: Harmful for Society, Harmful for the Workplace (campaignmonitor.com)

The ‘Model Minority’ Myth Explained. What you need to know about how it has propped up anti-Asian racism in Canada (thestar.com)

Special thanks to Rose Wu, Jennifer Lu, and Hanae Tsukada for their contributions!

Statement on the Missing Children of Canada’s Indian Residential Schools

IBPOC Connections: Building Community, Increasing Representation at UBC

“It’s the first time in my five to ten years at UBC that I’ve walked into a room where other people look like me. It’s the first time as a racialized person that I’m not being asked for something,” attendees of the IBPOC Connections inaugural luncheon told Dr. Maryam Nabavi, a staff and faculty strategist with the UBC Equity & Inclusion Office. Dr. Nabavi has been leading and championing IBPOC Connections since the launch of the initiative in 2019.

Dr. Maryam Nabavi, Staff and Faculty Strategist, UBC Equity & Inclusion Office

IBPOC Connections builds community and seeks to increase representation and cultivate belonging among staff and faculty who self-identify as Indigenous, Black, and/or People of Colour (IBPOC). Through luncheons, speaker series, and book and coffee clubs, IBPOC staff and faculty are invited to come together and celebrate their multiple and intersecting identities as well as speak candidly about the challenges they face at UBC.

“It is the historical and perennial whiteness of UBC that makes our attempt at community and the assertion of our presence necessary,” said Professor and Senior Advisor to the President on Anti-racism and Inclusive Excellence, Dr. Handel Kashope Wright, at the inaugural luncheon. Professor Wright, chair of the Task Force on Anti-Racism and Inclusive Excellence, describes IBPOC Connections as a way “to collectively make space for ourselves at UBC and to make interventions which will enhance our very survival and work lives at the university.”

“IBPOC Connections isn’t about building something anew,” said Dr. Nabavi. “Partnership is the bedrock of how we do our work.” The goal of IBPOC Connections is two-fold: to build community and to leverage existing networks to push for systemic change.

Dr. Sheryl Lightfoot, Senior Advisor to the President on Indigenous Affairs points out that “platforms like IBPOC Connections fill an important void to build community and amplify IBPOC voices in order to advance these objectives at the university.”

 

“If we can work together – with an understanding that although we bring unique perspectives and experiences, we do share collective goals, we can implement Indigenous human rights across the university and also break down other systemic barriers in order to make UBC a better and more just environment for all IBPOC individuals,” says Dr. Lightfoot, noting the connection to the Indigenous Strategic Plan and the efforts to reform policies and processes, reshape cultures and systems, and implement Indigenous human rights on our campuses.

 

Dr. Sheryl Lightfoot, Senior Advisor to the President on Indigenous Affairs

To design the program at UBC, Dr. Nabavi and colleagues from the UBC Equity & Inclusion Office conducted an environmental scan of similar initiatives across North American universities and hosted consultations with 25 IBPOC faculty and staff. They also convened an advisory committee of staff and faculty engaged in work on advancing equity and inclusion at UBC Vancouver.

“There was real energy and enthusiasm behind it,” said Dr. Sara-Jane Finlay, associate vice-president for equity and inclusion. “IBPOC Connections gained momentum incredibly quickly with real commitment coming from Ombudsperson for Students Shirley Nakata and Associate Professor Henry Yu.” In the first year alone, IBPOC Connections has recorded some 600 points of engagement with IBPOC staff and faculty.

Building a Sense of Belonging and Connection

As one of twenty institutional priorities in UBC’s strategic plan, inclusive excellence holds that diversity and inclusion are integral to excellence. IBPOC Connections is one of many efforts under the Inclusion Action Plan which operationalizes UBC’s commitment to inclusion. If we think of UBC’s strategic plan and the Inclusion Action Plan as roadmaps to inclusive excellence, then IBPOC Connections is a vehicle to understanding and enacting what inclusion really looks like.

Scholars use the term affinity spaces to refer to spaces of learning where people are brought together by shared interests or experiences. Affinity spaces have been widely adopted in higher education though their success has not always been forthcoming at UBC.

 

“Efforts to create formal affinity spaces for racialized staff and faculty are not new at UBC, and the work we are doing is informed by past efforts. University-wide commitments to inclusion, culminating in the Inclusion Action Plan in addition to newly formed leadership roles, such as the advisor to the president on anti-racism and inclusive excellence, have signalled a readiness and commitment to supporting IBPOC faculty and staff,” said Dr. Nabavi.

 

The deadly attack on mosques in Canada and abroad along with incidents of systemic racism in health care and law enforcement further amplified the need for spaces of belonging.

“There is a certain understanding of your life circumstances that only someone from your country, your region gets, no one else,” said Valentina Ruiz-Leotaud, a communications officer with the Sea Around Us initiative. Supported through the IBPOC Connections seed funding initiative that seeks to enable community groups to gather, Ruiz-Leotaud hosted an eight-week Zumba class. “I was almost in disbelief that this program existed. I was able to reach out and get funding to organize an activity that was about meeting people and doing something that really connects Latin people.”

Ruiz-Leotaud also took part in IGNITE Book Club, a speaker series and a book club organized and led by the Senior Advisor to the Provost on Racialized Faculty, Dr. Minelle Mahtani. The book club allows for the exploration and discussion of memoirs written by renowned racialized authors, with the intent of opening up space and stimulating dialogue and discussion around race and leadership.

“It’s a matter of not feeling like the other. As an immigrant when you gather with your people, you feel at home,” said Ruiz-Leotaud. IGNITE Book Club invited IBPOC Connections to partner on several events, expanding the range of engagement opportunities for IBPOC faculty and staff.

Similarly, IBPOC Connections Coffee Club provides staff with $10 gift cards to go for coffee with an IBPOC colleague. Other community-building events included speaker and performance-based events on topics like self-care and the contributions of BC’s Black community to the arts. 

Creating Pathways towards Leadership

Dr. Handel Kashope Wright, UBC Professor and Senior Advisor to the President on Anti-racism and Inclusive Excellence

IBPOC Connections seeks to enhance the experiences and outcomes of staff and faculty through capacity building, leadership development, recruitment and retention, and mentorship. For Professor Wright, IBPOC Connections is a “precursor to opportunities and initiatives for IBPOC faculty and staff to play an important role with respect to informing policies, processes, building a culture and creating opportunities to move toward a different experience than that of institutional betrayal.”

“Our sense of people’s experience has largely come from survey data, including from the 2019 Workplace Experiences Survey Pulse Report and the Employment Equity Report,” said Dr. Finlay. “The data tell us about barriers to advancement but what’s missing is the richness of their stories and lived experience.”

Dr. Nabavi points to a persistent lack of IBPOC staff in leadership roles, with data suggesting that IBPOC women are not advancing to leadership roles at the rate of their white counterparts. “It isn’t the case that they [IBPOC women] are not applying or aren’t qualified,” explained Dr. Nabavi. Racialized people represent 36.1 per cent of employees at UBC, a higher percentage than in the overall Canadian workforce (21.3 per cent) but lower than the in the Vancouver workforce (45.9 per cent).

To address this leadership gap, Dr. Nabavi and colleagues have developed a sponsorship model that outlines ways to support the retention and success of IBPOC women staff. Once the model is approved, a pilot initiative will match a staff member in a non-leadership role with a sponsor, two job categories above their position. The sponsor will provide coaching, mentorship, and opportunities to move into a different role.

“We are here in service to our students,” said Dr. Nabavi. “Initiatives such as the sponsorship pilot signal to IBPOC students that their identities are reflected in those who work at the university.”

Ruiz-Leotaud, a former UBC student herself, described her current workplace by saying, “I feel respected and valued for my abilities, not for where I come from or anything else.” Once IBPOC staff and faculty enter the university the focus must shift to their success, belonging, and career advancement. Affinity spaces are one such source of “inspiration and challenge,” said Dr. Finlay. “These spaces have the ability to be internal activists pushing the institution to do things differently.”

It won’t be easy. Dr. Nabavi likened this work to “constantly pushing a boulder up a hill. It means we have to create some discomfort and take risks.”

Funding Programs to Advance Inclusion and Anti-racism

UBC is committed to advancing equity and inclusion and to creating environments free from racism. To better respond to community needs and to support community involvement in building a more inclusive UBC, the following two funding streams are being made available to students, staff and faculty at UBC Vancouver and UBC Okanagan.

Activate Inclusion: Equity Enhancement Fund

The Activate Inclusion: Equity Enhancement Fund provides up to $15,000 in funding (per proposal) for community-based, collaborative projects designed to advance one or more of the actions outlined under the goals of Building Inclusive UBC: An Inclusion Action Plan.

Proposals should build student, faculty, and staff skills and understanding related to issues of equity, diversity, and inclusion through community-engaged activities while delivering observable and/or measurable benefits to the representation or experiences of historically disadvantaged groups within the UBC community.

Over the last ten years, the Equity Enhancement Fund has supported a vast array of exciting projects from podcasts to videos, resource groups to training programs, and from murals and artshows to dialogues and conferences.

For more information and to submit a proposal, please visit:

https://equity.ubc.ca/eef

Anti-Racism Initiatives Fund

UBC’s Anti-Racism Initiatives Fund specifically supports initiatives that advance anti-racism efforts and seek to celebrate and elevate diverse communities at UBC Vancouver and UBC Okanagan. $100,000 at UBCO and $100,000 at UBCV is available.

Funds may be used to host speakers, performances, and/or celebrate hallmark events in order to elevate, and build greater awareness and understanding of anti-racism and diversity at UBC. Applicants should take care that their proposal do not conflate cultural and anti-racism efforts.

For more information and to download an application form visit: https://antiracism.ubc.ca/resources/ubc-anti-racism-initiatives-fund/

 

Please encourage those in your faculties, portfolios, units and student communities to generate ideas, create proposals and apply for these by May 31, 2021.

We hope that these funds help spark collaboration and innovation across the university and accelerate efforts to advance the inclusion of those historically, persistently, or systemically marginalized, including Indigenous peoples, racialized people, women, people with disabilities and 2SLGBTQIA+ people.

 

Thank you,

Ainsley Carry

Vice-President, Student

Ananya Mukherjee Reed

Provost and Vice-President Academic, UBC Okanagan

Sara-Jane Finlay

Associate Vice-President, Equity & Inclusion

Dr. Ismaël Traoré Joins Provost’s Office as Director of Faculty Equity

Community Spotlight: Ashika Sharda

This International Women’s Day 2021, we decided to connect with inspiring women championing inclusion at UBC to hear their reflections on this day and perspectives on a more equitable and inclusive future.



Sociology student in the Faculty of Arts
Legal Assistant at Dhanu Dhaliwal Law Group

 

Over the course of this pandemic, many people including myself have used social media as a platform to advocate for marginalized communities. It has been evident during this pandemic just where women have been placed in many global issues. An important topic for me that I would like to shine a light on is the Kisaan (Farmers) Protest occurring in India. This protest is about farmers who have been forced to condone three bills that the Indian government has approved and implemented. As individuals that are living oceans away, as advocates who want to speak up for marginalized communities, social media has become a platform to advocate for these issues and to bring awareness to what is happening globally. The Kisaan protest is the largest protest to occur in human history, and women have been a large contributor to it. Elderly women to young girls are at the border – cooking, cleaning and holding their ground for their rights. They are fighting for the previous, present and future generations and fighting to get recognized as equals in this nation that continues to dehumanize its marginalized communities.

This International Woman’s day I want to focus not only on the woman who has broken the glass ceiling but the women who are still beneath the ceiling, cleaning up at the shards of glass leftover. The women who are lifting other women to reach the top, the ones who may not be recognized and often neglected, the ones who are seen as disposable, the ones that are never credited and the ones that help others in various ways that often go unseen. I want to challenge the norm of only celebrating only the women who have succeeded but also celebrating the women who have been the support systems.

 

Check out more spotlights!

Community Spotlight: Rabaab Khehra

This International Women’s Day 2021, we decided to connect with inspiring women championing inclusion at UBC to hear their reflections on this day and perspectives on a more equitable and inclusive future.


she/her/hers
Co-op student, Equity & Inclusion Office

 

How are you celebrating this International Women’s Day?

This International Women’s Day, I’m reflecting on the strength of my ancestors and the Indian women protesting against the farmers bills.

About 80% of farm work in India is undertaken by women and this bill will disproportionately affect them. Amongst many other things, in the name of free markers, this bill would weaken government intervention to ensure that farmers are paid a minimum price for their produce which leaves women without governmental support and especially vulnerable to negotiate within a male dominated marketplace.

Hence women have been protesting for months to ensure that their rights, and the rights of all farmers are protected. I am in awe of the strength of these women this women’s day and I would hope that everyone reading this takes some time today to reflect, research or donate.

 

Check out more spotlights!

Community Spotlight: Georgia Yee

This International Women’s Day 2021, we decided to connect with inspiring women championing inclusion at UBC to hear their reflections on this day and perspectives on a more equitable and inclusive future.


she/hers
AMS VP Academic and University Affairs

 

How can we bring about greater gender equality from within a university setting?

In order to bring about systemic change, we need to make leadership opportunities accessible to those who have been historically marginalized.
We really need to re-evaluate the way that we engage with leadership at UBC, and how we uplift historically marginalized voices. In addition to “listen” and “consult”, we need to directly have historically marginalized communities at the decision making tables and co-creating our plans forward for a more just society.
In my experience, I’ve been able to work with so many awesome women and people of colour that have acted as role models to me. I hope that through diverse representation in leadership, we can organize a community that is supportive, just, and representative.

 

Check out more spotlights!

Community Spotlight: Julia Burnham

This International Women’s Day 2021, we decided to connect with inspiring women championing inclusion at UBC to hear their reflections on this day and perspectives on a more equitable and inclusive future.


MA Student | Department of Educational Studies
Member of the UBC Vancouver Senate

 

What does IWD mean to you?
IWD, for me, is a day of gratitude to the women in my life who have held me up, shaped my values and have taught me everything I know.

 

What has your experience been like with leadership roles within and outside of UBC?
Having now run in three AMS Elections, I find myself thinking a lot about how things have changed over the years for women in student politics, and how things are still so much the same. I spend a lot of my time these days thinking about mentorship and the networks we build to hold each other up as we get talked over, underestimated and dismissed. Relationships are at the core of good advocacy and leadership, and it’s this part of the work that sustains me through the doubt and frustration.

 

One self-care tip that worked for you during these challenging times.

Finding a relaxing craft! I took up knitting in the pandemic and it’s brought me a lot of joy (and beautiful finished products to wear).

 

Check out more spotlights!